Best Place to Buy a Vintage Engagement Ring

Vintage Engagement Rings on Etsy

Are you shopping for a vintage engagement ring? Whether you’re attracted to the romance of a ring with a long history, want to avoid a modern mined diamond with all of the conflict, or simply want to save some money on this big purchase, vintage rings are always a smart choice.

If you’ve been searching for that perfect antique engagement ring locally, you may have become frustrated by a narrow offering available in your area. That’s why I strongly recommend checking out Etsy for a vintage engagement ring purchase for the best selection of antique and vintage engagement rings anywhere.

You may think of Etsy as the place to buy handcrafted goods but this international marketplace also hosts a large number of vintage and antique jewelry resellers. Many of them are retail jewelers who don’t want to incur the expense of opening their own online store to sell directly to customers outside their local area. Etsy lets them keep their costs down and still reach shoppers interested in their pieces, like you!

Here are 5 of the best Etsy sellers to check out when shopping for a vintage ring online.

My #1 Tip for Shopping for Jewelry on Etsy:

First, create an Etsy account. Then, click on the ♥️ icon on any products you love to save them to “your list.” You’ll then be notified via email when the seller drops their price on these items so you can save!

Bella Rosa Galleries

Bella Rosa Galleries has their physical store in Santa Barbara, California, but also sell their fine antique jewelry to shoppers everywhere via their Etsy storefront. With a discerning eye, their hand-selected engagement rings and fine jewelry span Edwardian, Art Deco and Modern Era rings. Many feature colored gemstones, delicate inlays, and exquisite antique cut diamonds.

(Clockwise from top)
Art Deco Diamond, Emerald and Sapphire Engagement Ring | Art Deco Platinum and Diamond Bezel Setting | Edwardian Filigree Aquamarine Engagement Ring | Edwardian Honeycomb Halo Engagement Ring

Your Jewelry Finder

Based out of Bethesda Maryland, Your Jewelry Finder has been selling on Etsy since 2013 and has racked up over 750 positive customer reviews. Specializing in Art Deco pieces from the early 1900’s, this seller has a good selection of antique, estate and vintage rings in the range of $2000-$3000. A recent visit to their Etsy storefront revealed these beauties:

(Clockwise from top)
1940’s Platinum and Diamond Cocktail-Style Ring | 1930’s Diamond and Sapphire Filigree Wedding Ring | Vintage Tiffany & Co. Solitaire with Old European-Cut Diamond | 1930’s Art Deco Platinum and Diamond Baguette Engagement Ring

Romanov Russia

Based in Chicago, Romanov Russia specializes in Victorian, Art Nouveau, Edwardian and original pieces from Imperial Russia. They also have a varied selection of halo and floral-halo rings with colored gemstones including ruby, emerald and sapphires. A look recently made popular by Katy Perry with her new floral halo ring from Orlando Bloom.

(Clockwise from top)
Antique Openwork Ring with Mine-Cut Diamond | Antique Sapphire Diamond Cluster Ring in Platinum | Emerald and Diamond Floral Cluster Ring in Yellow Gold | Old Mine Cut Diamond Cluster Ring Circa 1890

Wharfedale Antiques

Wharfedale Antiques, based in Leeds, UK, is a family-run business with over 40 years experience dealing in fine jewelry. Their unique pieces include Art Deco and Edwardian engagement rings. They also have a good assortment of diamond and gemstone wedding rings and eternity rings for those looking for an alternative to the traditional engagement ring. Plus, they offer Free Shipping to the United States.

(Clockwise from top)
Petite Diamond Engagement Ring | Art Deco Aquamarine Ring | Art Deco Diamond Cluster | Contemporary Art Deco Diamond and Ruby Halo Engagement Ring

Diamond Ten

Based in Dearborn Michigan, Diamond Ten has a wide selection of affordable diamond filigree engagement rings from the 1920’s plus an impressive selection of pre-owned Tiffany & Co. engagement rings from the pre-2000 era. Going for a pre-owned ring is a great way to get a genuine Tiffany & Co. ring for a steep discount. Their selection is worth taking a second look before buying new.

(Clockwise from top)
Love Bird Motif Vintage Engagement Ring | Tiffany & Co. Soleste w/Pink Diamonds circa 1980 | Tiffany & Co. Ribbon Ring Pre-2000 | Art Deco Diamond Engagement Ring w/French Cut Sapphires